Weatherly Insurance Agency, Inc

Our History

Weatherly Insurance Agency was established in 1984 by Keith and Gail Weatherly in Columbia, North Carolina, and then expanded to Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina, in 1989. Scott Weatherly then succeeded Keith as the Primary Agent in 2006. He and Jamie Weatherly are the current owners of Weatherly Insurance Agency. An additional location in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, was established in 2006. From the beginning, our agency has always strived to provide the best customer service possible. It is such a part of who we are as an agency, it is a portion of the Mission Statement in our Handbook - "Our guiding principle would be to treat EVERY client the way we would expect any professional to treat us when we are purchasing a service." We are a full-service agency offering products such as Homeowners, Auto, Business, Life, Motorcycle, RV, Personal Umbrella and Boat Insurance.

Why Us

Weatherly Insurance Agency is a 2nd generation Insurance agency. With 3 locations in eastern North Carolina, we are able to handle everything from the difficult Outer Banks insurance exposures, all the way to the farm trucks of the inland counties. We are a full service Insurance agency, with products ranging from Home, Auto and Life. We also have a Secondary Market for Second Homes and Rental Homes.

Our Locations

  • Pam Swain
  • 301 Main Street
  • PO Box 192
  • Columbia, NC 27925
  • (252) 796-5811
  • Scott Weatherly
  • 2810 N Croatan Hwy
  • Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948-9267
  • (252) 480-1284
Read More... Read Less...

Get an Insurance Quote


Get a Quote
  • Mon: 9:00 - 5:00
  • Tues: 9:00 - 5:00
  • Wed: 9:00 - 1:00
  • Thur: 9:00 - 5:00
  • Fri: 9:00 - 5:00
  • Sat: By Appt.
  • Sun: Closed
(252) 796-5811      MAP & DIRECTIONS