Anderson Robinson Starkey in Arcata, CA

Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service
1-800-421-35351-800-421-3535

Our Insurance Products

The Anderson Robinson Starkey in Arcata, CA provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    Choosing the right auto insurer can be tough. With so many options available, finding an insurer that is capable of meeting your needs and maintaining a good relationship with you are important. No matter the make and model of your vehicle, it is crucial for you to maintain a level of coverage that provides great protection from the uncertainties of the road. We work with Nationwide to give you the caliber of insurance protection you deserve.

    At Anderson Robinson Starkey in Arcata, we understand the need for complete transparency, good service, and affordable insurance coverage. That is why we work hard to provide a comprehensive offering of insurance products. Keeping your vehicle properly insured doesn't have to be a financial challenge. Whether you are shopping for coverage for yourself or your family, getting the right amount of protection is easy. When you choose us, you are getting a partner who works for you. Peace of mind and financial security are what you deserve, along with an insurer that addresses all of your concerns in an accurate and timely manner. We are committed to offering you the quality of products and services you need so you can live life on your terms.

    Call (707) 822-7251 to speak with Angela Crane Paye, or one of our other friendly and knowledgeable agents, at 1117 Samoa Blvd. We are more than happy to tell you more about our insurance offerings and how we can build a comprehensive policy that works best for your protection and financial needs.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    When you do business with Anderson Robinson Starkey, you deal with people who are adept at finding policies fitted to your needs and budget. There are several factors that should be considered when obtaining the right protection for your home in Arcata, including your ownership of a pool (or lack thereof) and the overall cost to rebuild your home. For expert assistance in sorting through all of the coverage options, get in touch with Angela Crane Paye or another helpful agent in our office. If you possess a large number of valuable assets such as jewelry or fine art, the protection offered by Valuables Plus® is a great choice and is something to discuss with your agent.

    At Anderson Robinson Starkey, we work together with Nationwide to bring you the best possible choices for your home insurance. We provide you with a selection experience that is smooth and intuitive so that you can get on with your daily life without additional stress. If you ever come home to find that you are a victim of a covered loss, we have what it takes to pick up the pieces. If you frequently experience severe weather conditions in your area, we can also help you find solutions for damage that may be caused by these storms.

    Speak with one of our agents today to get started on finding a hassle-free plan. If you would like to meet with someone in person, come to our office at 1117 Samoa Blvd. Or call us at (707) 822-7251.

  • Life Insurance

    If you have children, a spouse or anyone in your life who depends upon you financially, you need life insurance. The same holds true if you depend upon someone else financially. Life is unpredictable but it is within your power to minimize or even eliminate the financial impact of unexpected life events.

    We at Anderson Robinson Starkey are here to help people like you in the Arcata area. We are here to answer your questions and make life insurance understandable. We will explain term versus permanent insurance and we will outline the types of life insurance that may be best for you.

    When determining the amount of coverage you need, you should consider both your present and future circumstances. What are your current financial needs and what do you expect to be the future financial needs for your family?

    You should factor in your current age, income and debts and the likely financial impact of lost income. You should also consider final expenses as well as future educational needs for your children and even for yourself or your spouse. If you are a one-income household, you should be sure to purchase a policy that will cover that income in its entirety if lost.

    Life gets hectic; make sure you are not too busy to take care of yourself and your family. Call us now at (707) 822-7251 and ask for Angela Crane Paye. We are located at 1117 Samoa Blvd,Arcata,CA,95521 and you are welcome to stop in any time. Let us help you find the right policy to assure your family’s financial security.


    LAW-0248AO (05/18)

  • Business Insurance

    If you need an insurance policy that will provide coverage to your small business, you aren't alone. That is why business owners across the country turn to Nationwide to help them with their insurance needs. Small business owners are unique individuals, so a one-size-fits-all policy may or may not provide the coverage you are looking for. Nationwide agents can educate you about our products and help you customize a well-suited insurance package for you and your business. With us at your service, there is no need to put up with policies that don't serve you any longer.

    Property and liability insurance can both be necessary to keep your business safe. Property insurance can protect your physical location from damages caused by natural disasters, theft, and other misfortunes, and liability protects you from lawsuits filed by injured customers or third parties [note: liability does not protect against employee injuries]. There is no need to purchase each of these policies separately since Nationwide offers business owners policies (BOPs) to many types of qualifying businesses. These policies provide all of the aforementioned coverage and more if you choose to add on to your package.

    In addition to the coverage mentioned above, Nationwide also offers cyber liability, crime, accounts receivable, and income loss coverage due to an interruption. If you are interested in our products, Angela Crane Paye at Nationwide Insurance: Anderson Robinson Starkey in Arcata can help you find the right one. Stop by your local Nationwide agency on 1117 Samoa Blvd, or call (707) 822-7251 to learn more.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

The Anderson Robinson Starkey also offers products in CA, OR. Please call for information on products in those states.

Learning Center

Learning center articleHow does gap insurance work?

Discover what gap insurance does and how this auto policy can help you.

Learning center articleAre hazard and homeowners insurance the same?

Take a look at what make up the differences between hazard insurance and homeowners insurance.

Learning center articleComprehensive vs. collision insurance

Understand the differences between these two common types of auto insurance.