Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. in Erie, PA

Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service
1-800-421-35351-800-421-3535

Our Insurance Products

The Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. in Erie, PA provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    Whether you're changing vehicles or simply searching for better coverage this policy term, let Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. answer all your auto insurance questions. Our agents can ensure your policy meets all applicable PA requirements, while also pointing out areas where gaps in coverage may occur. We can help find your sweet spot between stronger coverage and affordable costs. You won't find a more knowledgeable, friendly source for personalized auto insurance in Erie.

    Area drivers will quickly come to realize the value that Nationwide brings to the table. This includes everything from policy discounts to flexible billing options to the On Your Side® Claims Service. But it also includes personalized policy options and exclusive programs from Nationwide that are popular with other Erie drivers Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. serves. Vanishing Deductible®, for example, is a great way to reward yourself for each year you stay claims-free.

    Our office address is 3132 Sterrettania Rd, but no matter which Erie zip code you park your car in, we can offer quick estimates and sound advice. Give us a call at (814) 833-0611. With one of our agents as your guide, it doesn't need to take all day to consider your choices.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Modern home insurance coverage is not one-size-fits-all, but is instead based on the unique aspects of your home and living in Erie. Some physical components to consider when covering your home are detached additions, like pools and sheds.

    Another aspect of home insurance is covering the belongings on the inside, the ones that are most valuable or the most important to you. For expensive works of art, antiques or jewelry, there is our Valuables Plus® coverage. If the unforeseen does happen, you can be covered with our Brand New Belongings® program which aids in the repair or replacement of your covered belongings. Whether you're covering priceless memories or expensive boutique items, and all our other local agents want to make sure you get the best coverage possible.

    The sheer number of coverage options and discounts can seem overwhelming, but not when you have Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. to explain every step along the way. We're located at 3132 Sterrettania Rd, but you can also call us at (814) 833-0611 to schedule an appointment or just ask questions.

  • Life Insurance

    Whenever you have any major change in your life, you should reassess your insurance needs. Marriage is one such occasion. Along with wedded bliss come new concerns and new responsibilities. You should take steps now to make sure that you and your spouse’s financial needs will be fully taken care of should the worst happen.

    We at Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. are here to help newlyweds in the Erie area. We will answer all your life insurance questions and explain in easy language term versus permanent insurance. After speaking with us, you will have a complete understanding of both whole life insurance and universal life insurance and you will know which options are best for you.

    In order to properly assess your coverage needs, you and your spouse will need to consider things such as your age, current income, current debt, number (if any) of dependent children, likely future income levels, final expenses and the impact of a loss of income. We will help you determine the amount and length of coverage that is optimal for your circumstances.

    After marriage, life gets busy. You should make sure, however that you are not too busy to take action now to assure a financially-secure future for yourself or your spouse years down the road. Life is uncertain but you can help take the uncertainty out of your financial future by making wise choices now.

    Call us at (814) 833-0611 and ask for . If you are in the neighborhood, we welcome you and your spouse to stop by our office at 3132 Sterrettania Rd,Erie,PA,16506. It may be the most important date of your life.


    LAW-0247AO (05/18)

  • Business Insurance

    Nationwide Insurance: Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. has the local knowledge and versatile insurance products to customize coverage for any small-to-medium-sized company in Erie. That said, even small businesses can have big business insurance needs. Liability, asset protection, commercial auto, employee insurance and other risk management tools apply to more than just the Fortune 500. Our agents have plenty of experience working with companies in virtually every Erie industry, from food and beverage to auto repair, as well as more niche markets. Nationwide Insurance: Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. can help your business understand how various coverage options work within your specific industry.

    More than just the industry, business insurance policy options are likely to be affected by the company's size, age, and location. Not to worry, our agents know the risks facing your business. Nationwide Insurance: Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. has the local knowledge to identify and explain how a particular location impacts a company's risk profile - regardless of whether or not you hung your shingle near our office.

    By partnering with Nationwide, it's easy to build a policy that manages the company's risk. In fact, with Nationwide's On Your Side® Review, business owners know that their coverage is keeping up with their evolving insurance priorities. Flexible billing and payment options can also manage the financial side of your business.

    Give Nationwide Insurance: Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. a call at (814) 833-0611. We can find a policy for your company quickly and confidently over the phone, or we can schedule a time to talk about your policy in person.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

The Crotty Insurance Agency Inc. also offers products in PA. Please call for information on products in those states.

Learning Center

Learning center articleHow does gap insurance work?

Discover what gap insurance does and how this auto policy can help you.

Learning center articleAre hazard and homeowners insurance the same?

Take a look at what make up the differences between hazard insurance and homeowners insurance.

Learning center articleDiscover what factors impact the cost of utilities

There are many different factors that can influence the amount of money you spend on utilities