Coronavirus Resources
Learn what steps Nationwide is taking and how to help protect yourself and others.
Karen R Bortnick, Insurance Agent

Karen Bortnick Agency in Goshen, NY

Karen R Bortnick


9:00 AM - 4:00 PM 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM 9:00 AM - 4:00 PMClosed Today Closed Today
Main Number
(914) 582-4235(914) 582-4235

Get an insurance quote

Get an insurance quote


Store Hours:

Day of the WeekHours
Mon9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Tue9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Wed9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Thu9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Fri9:00 AM - 4:00 PM


Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service

About Karen R Bortnick

Married with one beautiful son, James


  • Bachelor of Business Admistration - Public Accounting, minor in Law - Pace University. Licensed in Life & Health, Property & Casualty.

Languages Spoken

  • English
  • Hebrew
  • Spanish

Licensed In

  • ME
  • NJ
  • NY
  • PA


  • Auto
  • Life
  • Home
  • Business

Agent Qualifications

  • Licensed Insurance Agent/Broker in NY,NJ,PA and ME. Karen has serviced the tri-state area for over 15 years. Commercial Focus Promotion Market Winner 2014. Life University 2016

Community Activities

  • Member Professional Women of Westchester, Rochester Chamber of Commerce and Westchester-Putnam-Rockland Auto Body Association. We are very active within our community.

Our Insurance Products

The Nationwide Insurance: Karen Bortnick Agency in Goshen, NY provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    Whether you're changing vehicles or simply searching for better coverage this policy term, let Karen Bortnick Agency answer all your auto insurance questions. Our agents can ensure your policy meets all applicable NY requirements, while also pointing out areas where gaps in coverage may occur. We can help find your sweet spot between stronger coverage and affordable costs. You won't find a more knowledgeable, friendly source for personalized auto insurance in Goshen.

    Area drivers will quickly come to realize the value that Nationwide brings to the table. This includes everything from policy discounts to flexible billing options to the On Your Side® Claims Service. But it also includes personalized policy options and exclusive programs from Nationwide that are popular with other Goshen drivers Karen Bortnick Agency serves. Vanishing Deductible®, for example, is a great way to reward yourself for each year you stay claims-free.

    Our office address is 2002 Rt 17M, but no matter which Goshen zip code you park your car in, we can offer quick estimates and sound advice. Give us a call at (914) 582-4235. With one of our agents as your guide, it doesn't need to take all day to consider your choices.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Let Karen Bortnick Agency explain the policy choices needed to personalize a policy solution for any Goshen household. Our agents are ready to go through and explain the details of various coverage options. Goshen homeowners can quickly and clearly understand what's at stake when making their policy choices with Karen Bortnick Agency.

    More than just the versatile products, Karen Bortnick Agency knows the value of Nationwide's prices and services. Competitive rates and widely available discounts ensure affordable coverage for the homeowners who come to us for a policy. Plus, the renowned On Your Side® Claims Service offers immediate guidance on securing shelter, making temporary repairs and preventing further damage, as well as help on completing the claims process.

    Whether it's a 10924 home near our local office or a residential property throughout the city, the experts at Karen Bortnick Agency understand local risks right down to the exact block where the home is located. Let us make sure one of the most important investments you'll ever make doesn't go a single day without coverage. Talk to Karen Bortnick Agency or one of our other friendly, knowledgeable agents by calling (914) 582-4235. For those who wish to discuss their coverage in person, our office is located at 2002 Rt 17M.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Life Insurance

    Life is full of uncertainties. Your family’s financial well-being shouldn’t be one of them. As you shop for life insurance in Goshen, you likely have many questions running through your mind:

    • “What are the benefits of term vs. permanent policies?”
    • “How much coverage do I need?“
    • “How much does a life insurance policy cost?"

    Karen Bortnick Agency and Karen Bortnick Agency can help you find the right policy to protect your legacy and provide financial security for your loved ones when you are no longer living.

    There are a variety of factors you must consider to determine the amount of coverage you need. First, estimate the amount of debt, final expenses and other financial obligations you might leave behind. Also, think about your income and how the loss of it will affect your family. You want a policy that has a death benefit that covers those costs and leaves a financial cushion.

    Next, decide what kind of policy you want. There are several types of life insurance available. Base your decision on what you can comfortably afford and your current and future financial goals.

    Finally, carefully review all policy documents. A life insurance agent can provide clarity on any information or policy language you do not understand. If you have special considerations, do not hesitate to inform one of our team members.

    Insurance is a smart investment. Getting the right policy is easier than you think. Call (914) 582-4235 for an appointment with an agent. Feel free to stop by 2002 Rt 17M,Goshen,NY,10924 to discuss Nationwide coverage options in person.

    LAW-0239AO (05/18)

    Get an insurance quote

  • Business Insurance

    As a business owner, you're often the last person to leave the office or jobsite at the end of the day, but dedication has no doubt always been a part of your work ethic. At Karen Bortnick Agency in Goshen, we have a similar view. We're dedicated to providing outstanding insurance options that are customized to suit the needs of many different industries, and that's why we work with Nationwide. We can provide coverage that will help you protect and build your business so you have peace of mind.

    If yours is a manufacturing company, you may be looking for equipment breakdown coverage. If you have dozens of computers, you will probably want to check out cyber liability insurance that provides coverage for malicious hacking and damage to your computer system. On the other hand, you may be more interested in basic property insurance, which covers your losses from causes as diverse as fire, vandalism or damage from vehicles, or even airplanes. Asset protection can include everything from office equipment to accounting records to the satellite dish on your roof. The point is, insurance plans can be as varied as the reasons for needing coverage, and we would be happy to help you develop a plan customized to suit the requirements of your unique business.

    To learn more about commercial insurance, call Karen Bortnick Agency at (914) 582-4235 or drop by our 2002 Rt 17M office. You'll be amazed at the many options that are available for protecting the different aspects of your business. With the proper insurance coverage in place, you'll have one less thing to worry about when you finally leave work for the day.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

    Get an insurance quote

The Karen Bortnick Agency also offers products in ME, NY, PA, NJ. Please call for information on products in those states.

About the Karen Bortnick Agency

95 Allens Creek Rd
Ste 316
Rochester, NY 14618
Main Number
(585) 271-7683(585) 271-7683
Click to visit page of this location
At the Bortnick Agency, we know your needs are different than everyone else's. We know you want to be served quickly, professionally and personally. We want your experience with us to be helpful and rewarding. Our responsibility to you is to find you the right protection at the right cost. We are there for you with good advice as your needs or situation changes, and when it matters most, during a loss. We're here to protect all that is important to you from car insurance and home insurance to life insurance and business insurance. We match that protection to your lifestyle. The Bortnick Agency is a leader in technology and training, affording its customers only the best in speedy, accurate and friendly insurance services. Let us become your personal insurance or commercial insurance advisor, and the one who stands beside you in a loss. Our quotes are free, our advice is free, and our service is priceless. Become a member of our family and be treated as one too. We proudly serve Monroe County, Livingston County, Orange County, Dutchess County, Sullivan County, Rockland County, Westchester County, Kings County, Queens County, Bronx County, Richmond County, Nassau County, Suffolk County and New York County. Please come into our agency today to meet our friendly staff for all your insurance needs.
The Bortnick Agency staff consists of the perfect blend of experience, education and genuine concern for others. We do care about our customers and work hard for them every day. We make insurance easy... while ensuring comfort and security. The Bortnick Agency provides insurance products for individuals and businesses in. We are committed to superior customer service and offer competitive insurance products. Please visit our agency or call for your free quote today!

Average customer rating for Karen Bortnick Agency

2002 Rt 17M
Goshen, NY 10924