Coronavirus Resources
Learn what steps Nationwide is taking and how to help protect yourself and others.
Karen R Bortnick, Insurance Agent

Karen Bortnick Agency in Rochester, NY

Karen R Bortnick


9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PMClosed Today Closed Today
Main Number
(585) 271-7683(585) 271-7683

Get an insurance quote

Get an insurance quote


Store Hours:

Day of the WeekHours
Mon9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tue9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thu9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Fri9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service

About Karen R Bortnick

Married with one beautiful son, James


  • Bachelor of Business Admistration - Public Accounting, minor in Law - Pace University. Licensed in Life & Health, Property & Casualty.

Languages Spoken

  • English
  • Hebrew
  • Spanish

Licensed In

  • ME
  • NJ
  • NY
  • PA


  • Auto
  • Life
  • Home
  • Business

Agent Qualifications

  • Licensed Insurance Agent/Broker in NY,NJ,PA and ME. Karen has serviced the tri-state area for over 15 years. Commercial Focus Promotion Market Winner 2014. Life University 2016

Community Activities

  • Member Professional Women of Westchester, Rochester Chamber of Commerce and Westchester-Putnam-Rockland Auto Body Association. We are very active within our community.

Our Insurance Products

The Nationwide Insurance: Karen Bortnick Agency in Rochester, NY provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    Understanding the language of insurance policies can be difficult, which is why Karen Bortnick Agency focuses on being your guide to coverage whenever you ask for a quote on a new auto insurance policy. Whether you are looking to keep coverage on an older vehicle or you want to make sure your new purchase is fully protected, there are a variety of coverage options offered by Karen Bortnick Agency to fit any driver's needs in Rochester.

    Liability coverage is the first and most basic kind required by most states, but your optimum level of coverage and your state's minimum requirements might be quite different. It all depends on your individual needs starting with the vehicle you drive. Agents at Karen Bortnick Agency understand this, and part of the process of finding the right policy for each driver is finding the right combination of features. That means not only taking care of basic liability but also assessing your needs for collision insurance protection and comprehensive coverage to provide drivers with peace of mind even when the vehicle is parked.

    To ask questions about coverage or to talk to Karen Bortnick Agency about other discounts you might qualify for, give our offices a call at (585) 271-7683. We are also able to make appointments for face to face consultations at our office located at 95 Allens Creek Rd. Whether you want to know more about prices and coverage levels or you're ready to move forward with a purchase, our agency is ready to help with your auto insurance questions.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Let Karen Bortnick Agency explain the policy choices needed to personalize a policy solution for any Rochester household. Our agents are ready to go through and explain the details of various coverage options. Rochester homeowners can quickly and clearly understand what's at stake when making their policy choices with Karen Bortnick Agency.

    More than just the versatile products, Karen Bortnick Agency knows the value of Nationwide's prices and services. Competitive rates and widely available discounts ensure affordable coverage for the homeowners who come to us for a policy. Plus, the renowned On Your Side® Claims Service offers immediate guidance on securing shelter, making temporary repairs and preventing further damage, as well as help on completing the claims process.

    Whether it's a 14618 home near our local office or a residential property throughout the city, the experts at Karen Bortnick Agency understand local risks right down to the exact block where the home is located. Let us make sure one of the most important investments you'll ever make doesn't go a single day without coverage. Talk to Karen Bortnick Agency or one of our other friendly, knowledgeable agents by calling (585) 271-7683. For those who wish to discuss their coverage in person, our office is located at 95 Allens Creek Rd.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Life Insurance

    Whenever you have any major change in your life, you should reassess your insurance needs. Marriage is one such occasion. Along with wedded bliss come new concerns and new responsibilities. You should take steps now to make sure that you and your spouse’s financial needs will be fully taken care of should the worst happen.

    We at Karen Bortnick Agency are here to help newlyweds in the Rochester area. We will answer all your life insurance questions and explain in easy language term versus permanent insurance. After speaking with us, you will have a complete understanding of both whole life insurance and universal life insurance and you will know which options are best for you.

    In order to properly assess your coverage needs, you and your spouse will need to consider things such as your age, current income, current debt, number (if any) of dependent children, likely future income levels, final expenses and the impact of a loss of income. We will help you determine the amount and length of coverage that is optimal for your circumstances.

    After marriage, life gets busy. You should make sure, however that you are not too busy to take action now to assure a financially-secure future for yourself or your spouse years down the road. Life is uncertain but you can help take the uncertainty out of your financial future by making wise choices now.

    Call us at (585) 271-7683 and ask for Karen Bortnick Agency. If you are in the neighborhood, we welcome you and your spouse to stop by our office at 95 Allens Creek Rd,Rochester,NY,14618. It may be the most important date of your life.

    LAW-0247AO (05/18)

    Get an insurance quote

  • Business Insurance

    Whether you operate a golf course, medical clinic, or auto repair shop, coverage from Nationwide can fulfill all the small business insurance requirements that apply to Rochester companies. Let Karen Bortnick Agency help make sure that your customers and employees are protected, while also allowing your company to move forward when covered damages do occur.

    The versatile risk management products from Nationwide are backed by strong value, attractive discounts, and the superior On Your Side® Claims Service. Moreover, flexible billing helps meet your financial scheduling needs, while different payment options can prevent insurance from becoming another logistical hassle. From customized policies to good old fashioned customer service, it's all part of the package Karen Bortnick Agency offers our Rochester business clients.

    No matter how well you know your business, there always seems to be a few lingering questions about the right coverage for your company. Whether it's the location of your storefront, the size of your commercial fleet, or the feasibility of new employee benefits, let Karen Bortnick Agency answer any and all questions you might have. Give us a call at (585) 271-7683 to talk about your coverage or to schedule an office appointment at 95 Allens Creek Rd.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

    Get an insurance quote

The Karen Bortnick Agency also offers products in ME, NY, PA, NJ. Please call for information on products in those states.

About the Karen Bortnick Agency

2002 Rt 17M
Goshen, NY 10924
Main Number
(914) 582-4235(914) 582-4235
Click to visit page of this location
At the Bortnick Agency, we know your needs are different than everyone else's. We know you want to be served quickly, professionally and personally. We want your experience with us to be helpful and rewarding. Our responsibility to you is to find you the right protection at the right cost. We are there for you with good advice as your needs or situation changes, and when it matters most, during a loss. We're here to protect all that is important to you from car insurance and home insurance to life insurance and business insurance. We match that protection to your lifestyle. The Bortnick Agency is a leader in technology and training, affording its customers only the best in speedy, accurate and friendly insurance services. Let us become your personal insurance or commercial insurance advisor, and the one who stands beside you in a loss. Our quotes are free, our advice is free, and our service is priceless. Become a member of our family and be treated as one too. We proudly serve Monroe County, Livingston County, Orange County, Dutchess County, Sullivan County, Rockland County, Westchester County, Kings County, Queens County, Bronx County, Richmond County, Nassau County, Suffolk County and New York County. Please come into our agency today to meet our friendly staff for all your insurance needs.
The Bortnick Agency staff consists of the perfect blend of experience, education and genuine concern for others. We do care about our customers and work hard for them every day. We make insurance easy... while ensuring comfort and security. The Bortnick Agency provides insurance products for individuals and businesses in. We are committed to superior customer service and offer competitive insurance products. Please visit our agency or call for your free quote today!

Average customer rating for Karen Bortnick Agency

95 Allens Creek Rd
Ste 316
Rochester, NY 14618