McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency in Worthington, OH

Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service
1-800-421-35351-800-421-3535

Our Insurance Products

The McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency in Worthington, OH provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    Just as not all vehicles are the same, not all auto insurance policies are the same. Christina Lynn Kelly specializes in creating auto insurance plans unique to your driving conditions and the demands of Worthington. As a representative of Nationwide, you can rest knowing that your automobile is covered.

    We make it simple and quick for you to get the auto coverage you need for your vehicle. The McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency also breaks down your insurance coverage in terms you can easily understand, which goes a long way in giving you confidence that you and your car are truly protected. Simply let us know if there are any special add-ons you'd like to include in your coverage, or if there are any changes you'd like to make to your insurance. Additionally, we'll work with you to see if you qualify for any of Nationwide's insurance discounts. Be sure you keep us updated on any major cosmetic modifications or additions you make on your vehicle, as they might require a change to your policy.

    Christina Lynn Kelly doesn't take any chances when it comes to supplying members with complete auto insurance at a great cost. Call us today at (614) 888-4540, or you're more than welcome to pay us a visit at our office located at 250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd. We look forward to providing auto insurance to meet your wants and needs.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Homeowners insurance is a crucial part of owning and protecting a home. That's why the McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency has worked so diligently to understand the insurance priorities of 43085 homeowners and their residential properties. In fact, the exact location of your home may mean your home's risk profile is slightly different from that of your Worthington neighbors' right down the street. No matter the specifics, Nationwide has coverage that's right for your Worthington home, and our agents can help further personalize your homeowner's policy.

    How so? Beyond the location, the property itself often has very different kinds of assets that can be protected through home insurance coverage. The structure and dwelling coverage are the backbone of most policies, but McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency offers plenty of additional coverage options through Nationwide. These options cover things like a detached garage or other buildings, contents and valuables, or even a number of exclusive coverage programs like Better Roof Replacement®. Plus, if the time ever comes when one or more of our homeowners need to return a home to its former glory, the Nationwide On Your Side® Claims Service offers extra peace of mind.

    Our office is located at 250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd. But our home insurance expertise extends throughout the greater Worthington area. Call the McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency at (614) 888-4540 to get our take on the best way to protect against potential homeowner damages.

  • Life Insurance

    If you have children, a spouse or anyone in your life who depends upon you financially, you need life insurance. The same holds true if you depend upon someone else financially. Life is unpredictable but it is within your power to minimize or even eliminate the financial impact of unexpected life events.

    We at McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency are here to help people like you in the Worthington area. We are here to answer your questions and make life insurance understandable. We will explain term versus permanent insurance and we will outline the types of life insurance that may be best for you.

    When determining the amount of coverage you need, you should consider both your present and future circumstances. What are your current financial needs and what do you expect to be the future financial needs for your family?

    You should factor in your current age, income and debts and the likely financial impact of lost income. You should also consider final expenses as well as future educational needs for your children and even for yourself or your spouse. If you are a one-income household, you should be sure to purchase a policy that will cover that income in its entirety if lost.

    Life gets hectic; make sure you are not too busy to take care of yourself and your family. Call us now at (614) 888-4540 and ask for Christina Lynn Kelly. We are located at 250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd,Worthington,OH,43085 and you are welcome to stop in any time. Let us help you find the right policy to assure your family’s financial security.


    LAW-0248AO (05/18)

  • Business Insurance

    As a business owner, you make scores of decisions every day. Some of those have to do with the insurance you carry. Do you have enough? Have you added more employees or purchased new equipment? Are you covered for computer attacks? In other words, have there been changes that indicate a review is in order? At Nationwide Insurance: McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency, we have answers for those questions and many more. Because we work with Nationwide, we can provide you with a wealth of insurance solutions customized specifically to the type of company you own.

    We believe that the insurance you purchase should fit your business like a glove. The basics include property and liability insurance, but there are many other kinds of protection, and what you need depends on what you own. It's a good idea to take stock, listing assets such as buildings, vehicles, office and manufacturing equipment, inventory kept on the premises, fencing, landscaping, signage – even your satellite dish. This is the kind of information our insurance specialists will use help you design the coverage you need.

    At Nationwide Insurance: McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency, we know that most of your waking hours are consumed by your business: how to run it, how to build it, and how to protect it. When it comes to concerns about insurance coverage, we can help make sense of a subject that sometimes seems overly complex. All you have to do is call Christina Lynn Kelly at (614) 888-4540, or stop by our Worthington office on 250 W Old Wilson Bridge Rd. You'll get prompt answers to the questions you have about protecting your business and, better yet, solutions to put your mind at ease.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

The McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency also offers products in AZ, CA, CO, CT, DE, DC, GA, ID, IL, IN, KS, MD, MI, MN, MO, MT, NE, NV, NH, NM, OH, OR, PA, SC, TX, UT, VT, VA, WA, WV, WY, KY. Please call for information on products in those states.

Learning Center

Learning center articleHow does gap insurance work?

Discover what gap insurance does and how this auto policy can help you.

Learning center articleAre hazard and homeowners insurance the same?

Take a look at what make up the differences between hazard insurance and homeowners insurance.

Learning center articleDiscover what factors impact the cost of utilities

There are many different factors that can influence the amount of money you spend on utilities