Michael McGuire, Insurance Agent

Michael A McGuire Agency in Westerville, OH

Michael McGuire

Agency President

9:00 AM - 6:00 PM 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:30 PMClosed Today Closed Today
Main Number
(614) 888-9494(614) 888-9494

Get an insurance quote

Get an insurance quote


(614) 888-9494(614) 888-9494
(614) 888-8990(614) 888-8990


Store Hours:

Day of the WeekHours
Mon9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tue9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wed9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thu9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Fri9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service

About Michael McGuire

Resides in Bexley with wife and three daughters.


  • Bachelor of Arts degree form The Ohio State University

Languages Spoken

  • English

Licensed In

  • OH
  • PA


  • Auto
  • Life
  • Home
  • Business

Agent Qualifications

  • Holds licenses in Property & Casualty and Life & Health


  • Champion Award
  • Nationwide Auto Council

Community Activities

  • Member of St Catharine Church in Bexley and OSU Alumni Association.

Our Insurance Products

The Nationwide Insurance: Michael A McGuire Agency in Westerville, OH provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    Many terms associated with auto insurance can be confusing. For example, what does "comprehensive car insurance" mean? You will get answers to questions and much more when talking about your insurance needs with Michael A McGuire Agency. We work with Nationwide to bring you excellent service and coverage in Westerville.

    Most states require the purchase of liability coverage. This coverage protects you when you become legally liable for damage to another auto or someone else's injuries from a car accident. Comprehensive coverage provides additional protection for your vehicle from loss due to theft, fire, hail, and other factors. Other offerings include Medical Payments or Personal Injury Protection coverage, and features such as Roadside Assistance.

    Give Michael A McGuire Agency or another experienced agent a call today at (614) 888-9494. Drivers can discuss options over the phone or in person at 435 Lazelle Rd.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Michael A McGuire Agency can help you shop for one of the most important products you'll ever buy - the home insurance policy that will protect your home assets. Learn from our Westerville agents what types of damages to include in your coverage and what claim amounts make sense for your property. For as tightly knit as Westerville neighborhoods are, no two households are exactly the same, even within 43081.

    For this reason, Nationwide offers a number of different home insurance products for more personalized coverage. Dwelling coverage, for example, offers financial protection for floor coverings and built-in appliances. Contents coverage includes assets like furniture, clothing, and a few other essential belongings. Valuables Plus® covers specific types of high-value items that you may keep in your Westerville home. Or you can even take advantage of Nationwide's exclusive Brand New Belongings® program.

    Best of all, there's no reason to feel overwhelmed by any of these decisions. Let Michael A McGuire Agency walk you through the options and clearly explain your policy choices. Simply give us a call at (614) 888-9494. Or, if you're in the 43081 area during office hours, swing by our Westerville location at 435 Lazelle Rd, and we can discuss your home insurance options in person.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Life Insurance

    Bringing home a new baby, like many of life’s happy events, also brings on new responsibilities. New obligations can be more easily shouldered if you take steps now to plan ahead. In order to provide long-term financial security for your family, you need a Westerville life insurance agent who can help you understand the types of life insurance that best suit your family’s needs.

    The agents at Michael A McGuire Agency will help you safeguard your family’s future by helping you select the right life insurance. We will explain term versus permanent insurance and answer all your questions. We are here to help you assess your needs and will explain the difference between whole life insurance and universal life insurance.

    Our agency will help you determine the appropriate level of coverage for you and your family. There are several considerations when deciding the amount of coverage you need. Besides funeral and burial costs, you should consider current debts such as your mortgage, car loans and credit card debt.

    You may also want to include child care and long-term educational expenses when figuring coverage amount. Whether your family has one or two sources of income, you should think about covering lost income for a specified number of years. We will also help you determine the number of years for which you need coverage.

    Whether you have a new baby on the way, or you brought your baby home several months ago, now is the time to plan for life’s eventualities. Call (614) 888-9494 and ask for Michael McGuire or visit us at 435 Lazelle Rd,Westerville,OH,43081. We will be happy to work with you to make sure your family’s financial security is always protected.

    LAW-0245AO (05/18)

    Get an insurance quote

  • Business Insurance

    No Westerville business should be left without quality insurance protection. Michael McGuire and the rest of us here at Michael A McGuire Agency specialize in providing coverage to local business owners so that their employees, finances, physical grounds, and offices are well-protected. We eliminate any guesswork that may be involved with insurance plans and replace it with confidence and reassurance.

    Nationwide is known for its stellar attention to detail when it comes to various insurance protections, which is why we've teamed up with them to bring you a dependable plan for your business and your employees. We aren't satisfied until we've helped you create a quality plan as well as identified each discount to which you're entitled. Michael McGuire knows that equipment can break down, that your business operations can be interrupted, and that your employees may become injured. No matter the situation, your plan should account for it, which is exactly where we come in. Once we've set you up with coverage, we hope you'll keep us up to date on any changes you're making to your business in order that your plan always reflects your most current needs.

    Stop by our office located at 435 Lazelle Rd when you're ready to learn more about Nationwide insurance. You're also welcome to give us a call at (614) 888-9494.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

    Get an insurance quote

The Michael A McGuire Agency also offers products in OH, PA. Please call for information on products in those states.

About the Michael A McGuire Agency

James McGuire, Insurance Agent

James McGuire Associate Agent/Vice President

(614) 888-9494(614) 888-9494
(614) 888-8990(614) 888-8990
Bradley Schimmoeller, Insurance Agent

Bradley Schimmoeller Associate

(614) 888-9494(614) 888-9494
(614) 888-8990(614) 888-8990
Sandra Pooler, Insurance Agent

Sandra Pooler Customer Service Specialist

(614) 888-9494(614) 888-9494
(614) 888-8990(614) 888-8990
The McGuire Insurance Group has been in existence for over 50 years serving the insurance needs of central Ohio. Our top priority is doing what's best for you. We'll provide you with the right coverage at the right price. When you suffer a loss, we are your first contact. We'll make sure you get fair, prompt payment. Our service is a little old fashioned we believe it is essential to answer your question the day it was asked. We follow up with you on all claims making sure things are right. Our family owned business looks forward to doing business with you and your family.
This is a locally family-owned agency serving central Ohio for the past 45 years. We provide advice and counsel to the family insurance market place.

Average customer rating for Michael A McGuire Agency

435 Lazelle Rd
Westerville, OH 43081