Mike Merhar, Insurance Agent

The Merhar Agency LLC

Mike Merhar
Agency Owner
9:00 AM - 5:30 PM 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM 9:00 AM - 5:30 PMClosed Today Closed Today

Send The Merhar Agency LLC an Email

Main Number
(440) 946-2040(440) 946-2040

Get an insurance quote

Get an insurance quote

(440) 946-2040(440) 946-2040
(440) 510-8660(440) 510-8660

Send Mike Merhar an Email


Store Hours:

Day of the WeekHours
Mon9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Tue9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Wed9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Thu9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Fri9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Learn about our insurance products

  • Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.
  • Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.
  • Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.
  • Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service

About Mike Merhar

Languages Spoken
  • English
Licensed In
  • OH
  • PA
  • Auto
  • Life
  • Home
  • Business
  • Champion Award
  • Million Dollar Round Table
  • Presidents Conference Award

Our Insurance Products

The Nationwide Insurance: The Merhar Agency LLC in Willoughby, OH provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.
  • Auto Insurance
    When looking for insurance, what matters most is coverage you can rely on if things go wrong. That's why Mike Merhar works with Nationwide to provide you with a personalized and affordable plan. We know every situation is different, which is why we offer a variety of solutions to common insurance needs. Whether you have one car and one driver or many cars and multiple drivers, The Merhar Agency LLC is ready to help you navigate selecting car insurance.

    At Nationwide, we're here when you need us. We make vehicle claims quick and simple by providing a list of repair shops we have pre-screened for quality and professionalism. We are local to the Willoughby area so we know what is important for vehicles in this part of the country, from weather to general use. We'll spend as long as it takes to make sure you understand your coverage.

    When you contact The Merhar Agency LLC, you'll get the benefit of all Nationwide's discounts which you may qualify for. There are discounts for every stage of life, from good student discounts to safe driver discounts. We will even discuss discounts for eco-friendly billing. Call today at (440) 946-2040 or come visit us in person at 4077 Clark Ave. We look forward to making you part of our member community.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Homeowners Insurance
    The Merhar Agency LLC can help you shop for one of the most important products you'll ever buy - the home insurance policy that will protect your home assets. Learn from our Willoughby agents what types of damages to include in your coverage and what claim amounts make sense for your property. For as tightly knit as Willoughby neighborhoods are, no two households are exactly the same, even within 44094.

    For this reason, Nationwide offers a number of different home insurance products for more personalized coverage. Dwelling coverage, for example, offers financial protection for floor coverings and built-in appliances. Contents coverage includes assets like furniture, clothing, and a few other essential belongings. Valuables Plus® covers specific types of high-value items that you may keep in your Willoughby home. Or you can even take advantage of Nationwide's exclusive Brand New Belongings® program.

    Best of all, there's no reason to feel overwhelmed by any of these decisions. Let The Merhar Agency LLC walk you through the options and clearly explain your policy choices. Simply give us a call at (440) 946-2040. Or, if you're in the 44094 area during office hours, swing by our Willoughby location at 4077 Clark Ave, and we can discuss your home insurance options in person.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Life Insurance
    Life is full of uncertainties. Your family’s financial well-being shouldn’t be one of them. As you shop for life insurance in Willoughby, you likely have many questions running through your mind:

    • “What are the benefits of term vs. permanent policies?”
    • “How much coverage do I need?“
    • “How much does a life insurance policy cost?"

    The Merhar Agency LLC and Mike Merhar can help you find the right policy to protect your legacy and provide financial security for your loved ones when you are no longer living.

    There are a variety of factors you must consider to determine the amount of coverage you need. First, estimate the amount of debt, final expenses and other financial obligations you might leave behind. Also, think about your income and how the loss of it will affect your family. You want a policy that has a death benefit that covers those costs and leaves a financial cushion.

    Next, decide what kind of policy you want. There are several types of life insurance available. Base your decision on what you can comfortably afford and your current and future financial goals.

    Finally, carefully review all policy documents. A life insurance agent can provide clarity on any information or policy language you do not understand. If you have special considerations, do not hesitate to inform one of our team members.

    Insurance is a smart investment. Getting the right policy is easier than you think. Call (440) 946-2040 for an appointment with an agent. Feel free to stop by 4077 Clark Ave,Willoughby,OH,44094 to discuss Nationwide coverage options in person.

    LAW-0239AO (05/18)

    Get an insurance quote

  • Business Insurance
    The Merhar Agency LLC has the local knowledge and versatile insurance products to customize coverage for any small-to-medium-sized company in Willoughby. That said, even small businesses can have big business insurance needs. Liability, asset protection, commercial auto, employee insurance and other risk management tools apply to more than just the Fortune 500. Our agents have plenty of experience working with companies in virtually every Willoughby industry, from food and beverage to auto repair, as well as more niche markets. The Merhar Agency LLC can help your business understand how various coverage options work within your specific industry.

    More than just the industry, business insurance policy options are likely to be affected by the company's size, age, and location. Not to worry, our agents know the risks facing your business. The Merhar Agency LLC has the local knowledge to identify and explain how a particular location impacts a company's risk profile - regardless of whether or not you hung your shingle near our office.

    By partnering with Nationwide, it's easy to build a policy that manages the company's risk. In fact, with Nationwide's On Your Side® Review, business owners know that their coverage is keeping up with their evolving insurance priorities. Flexible billing and payment options can also manage the financial side of your business.

    Give The Merhar Agency LLC a call at (440) 946-2040. We can find a policy for your company quickly and confidently over the phone, or we can schedule a time to talk about your policy in person.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

    Get an insurance quote

The The Merhar Agency LLC also offers products in OH, PA. Please call for information on products in those states.

About the The Merhar Agency LLC

Bryan J Noda, Insurance Agent

Bryan J Noda Associate Agent

(440) 946-2040(440) 946-2040
(440) 510-8660(440) 510-8660

Send Bryan J Noda an Email

Max Merhar, Insurance Agent

Max Merhar Associate Agent/Vice President

(440) 946-2040(440) 946-2040
(440) 510-8660(440) 510-8660

Send Max Merhar an Email

James Zeiger, Insurance Agent

James Zeiger Associate Agent/Customer Service

(440) 946-2040(440) 946-2040
(440) 510-8660(440) 510-8660

Send James Zeiger an Email

Darlene Noda Phillips, Insurance Agent

Darlene Noda Phillips Agent/Office Manager

(440) 946-2040(440) 946-2040
(440) 510-8660(440) 510-8660

Send Darlene Noda Phillips an Email

35401 Euclid Ave
Ste 212
Willoughby, OH 44094
Main Number
(440) 953-1441(440) 953-1441
Click to visit page of this location
30184 Euclid Ave
Wickliffe, OH 44092
Main Number
(440) 585-4404(440) 585-4404
Click to visit page of this location
Established in 1955, The Merhar Agency has proudly served its members and community, for over 50 years and through 3 generations! The Merhar Agency, is recognized as one of Nationwide's few Heritage Agencies, so if you're looking for expert insurance consultation and policies that are tailored of your individual needs, contact us today for a free insurance consultation at 440-946-2040. Devoted Experts: Lou Merhar- 1955 to 1977 Jerry Merhar- 1975 to current Mike and Max Merhar- 2002 to current Lou Merhar started the agency in 1955. For the next 30 yrs. Lou grew the agency through hard work and community involvement. Along with his work in the agency and the community, Lou was also a compassionate father of two sons. Growing up Jerry and Jim were taught the importance of hard work and what it means to be apart of a community. After graduating from college both sons managed to find their way back into careers with Nationwide Insurance. Jerry ran the agency from 1977 to March 2013, Jerry remains an active within The Merhar Agency as well as the community. He is an active member of the Willoughby Chamber of Commerce, the Kiwanis and Rotary clubs. Through his hard work Jerry has become respected within the community and was honored by the Willoughby Area Chamber of Commerce as "Distinguished Citizen" in 1993. Along the way he has achieved many milestones within Nationwide, including; 7 Presidents Conference awards, 34 Conference of Champion awards, Agency of the Year in his district along with many others. As of March 2013, Jerry's two sons Mike and Max have began a 3rd generation of The Merhar Agency. Mike and Max, both Kent State graduates and life long residents of Willoughby are now working together to maintain their families commitment to the community and the members they serve at the agency. They grew up in the agency, learning from their father's example just as he had done many years ago.
The Merhar Agency has been serving North East Ohio as a full service insurance agency for over 50 yrs. We understand that insurance is not a "one size fits all" service, so we customize our coverage to meet the individual needs of our members. This approach to business has earned The Merhar Agency a trusted reputation as being "On Your Side" when you need it most.

Average customer rating for The Merhar Agency LLC

4077 Clark Ave
Willoughby, OH 44094