Nuthak Insurance LLC

Learn about our insurance products

  • Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.
  • Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.
  • Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.
  • Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service
1-800-421-35351-800-421-3535

Our Insurance Products

The Nuthak Insurance LLC in Shelbyville, IN provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance
    Choosing the right auto insurer can be tough. With so many options available, finding an insurer that is capable of meeting your needs and maintaining a good relationship with you are important. No matter the make and model of your vehicle, it is crucial for you to maintain a level of coverage that provides great protection from the uncertainties of the road. We work with Nationwide to give you the caliber of insurance protection you deserve.

    At Nuthak Insurance LLC in Shelbyville, we understand the need for complete transparency, good service, and affordable insurance coverage. That is why we work hard to provide a comprehensive offering of insurance products. Keeping your vehicle properly insured doesn't have to be a financial challenge. Whether you are shopping for coverage for yourself or your family, getting the right amount of protection is easy. When you choose us, you are getting a partner who works for you. Peace of mind and financial security are what you deserve, along with an insurer that addresses all of your concerns in an accurate and timely manner. We are committed to offering you the quality of products and services you need so you can live life on your terms.

    Call (317) 392-8732 to speak with Stephen Nuthak, or one of our other friendly and knowledgeable agents, at 701 N Harrison St. We are more than happy to tell you more about our insurance offerings and how we can build a comprehensive policy that works best for your protection and financial needs.
  • Homeowners Insurance
    Nuthak Insurance LLC can help you shop for one of the most important products you'll ever buy - the home insurance policy that will protect your home assets. Learn from our Shelbyville agents what types of damages to include in your coverage and what claim amounts make sense for your property. For as tightly knit as Shelbyville neighborhoods are, no two households are exactly the same, even within 46176.

    For this reason, Nationwide offers a number of different home insurance products for more personalized coverage. Dwelling coverage, for example, offers financial protection for floor coverings and built-in appliances. Contents coverage includes assets like furniture, clothing, and a few other essential belongings. Valuables Plus® covers specific types of high-value items that you may keep in your Shelbyville home. Or you can even take advantage of Nationwide's exclusive Brand New Belongings® program.

    Best of all, there's no reason to feel overwhelmed by any of these decisions. Let Nuthak Insurance LLC walk you through the options and clearly explain your policy choices. Simply give us a call at (317) 392-8732. Or, if you're in the 46176 area during office hours, swing by our Shelbyville location at 701 N Harrison St, and we can discuss your home insurance options in person.
  • Life Insurance
    At Nuthak Insurance LLC, we want to make customers aware of how easy and affordable life insurance is. We know many people in Shelbyville think they cannot afford to have a good policy that protects their financial interests. That is why we work with Nationwide to provide customers with the diverse coverage options they need to sleep peacefully at night.

    Affordability is a major concern for most. In addition to choosing coverage based on what you can afford, you need to think about how you or your loved ones may need to use your policy proceeds. Maybe you’ll need to replace lost income or pay for long-term care expenses and your kids’ college education. These issues may not completely encompass your current concerns. However, keeping them in mind will help you discern the proper coverage level for your situation.

    There are circumstances where customers find it more beneficial for them to layer several term life insurance policies instead of purchasing whole life insurance to give them long-term financial security.

    By speaking with a life insurance agent who works with Nationwide, you can gain a better understanding of options that are ideal for your situation. The amount of coverage you need can help you meet your current and future financial goals.

    To better understand coverage options, we encourage you to contact Stephen Nuthak at (317) 392-8732 to arrange a time to meet in office at 701 N Harrison St,Shelbyville,IN,46176 to discuss your needs. For additional convenience, our agents are ready to help you go over coverage options over the phone.


    LAW-0244AO (05/18)
  • Business Insurance
    Like most business owners, you probably know pretty much everything about your business. Still, you may have lingering questions about your commercial insurance needs. The Nationwide Insurance: Nuthak Insurance LLC can fill the gaps in your knowledge of Shelbyville business insurance, just as we can recognize and fill gaps in your policy coverage.

    Maybe you have questions about a business owner's policy or industry-specific coverage programs available from Nationwide. Maybe you have questions about different commercial insurance products including liability, property, and employee coverage. But no matter your concerns, you want to know that your business's past success has been safeguarded, while also putting your company in a great position for future growth.

    In addition to their great insurance products, the Nationwide Insurance: Nuthak Insurance LLC also partners with Nationwide for superior account services. For example, whether you need to respond to changes in state law or local markets, don't underestimate the value of the Nationwide's On Your Side® Reviews. Let us explain how dependable customer service and flexible billing options make for stronger protection for your Shelbyville company. Give us a call at (317) 392-8732 so we can start discussing your business's insurance needs. We can also set up a time to talk in person at our local office. We're located at 701 N Harrison St.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

The Nuthak Insurance LLC also offers products in IN. Please call for information on products in those states.

Learning Center

Learning center articleHow does gap insurance work?
Discover what gap insurance does and how this auto policy can help you.
Take a look at what make up the differences between hazard insurance and homeowners insurance.
Learning center articleDiscover what factors impact the cost of utilities
There are many different factors that can influence the amount of money you spend on utilities