About Our Agency
Community Involvement
Languages Spoken
- English
Areas Served
We serve all of Ohio! As a local, family-owned agency we value relationships built on knowledge, trust, and integrity. Stop by our office or call for a quote.

| Day of the Week | Hours |
|---|---|
| Mon | 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM |
| Tue | 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM |
| Wed | 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM |
| Thu | 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM |
| Fri | 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
We serve all of Ohio! As a local, family-owned agency we value relationships built on knowledge, trust, and integrity. Stop by our office or call for a quote.
Our agency specializes in Agriculture, Auto, Commercial, Condo, Farm, Home, Powersports, Renters insurance.
Your Nationwide Insurance ID card can be accessed here.
There's nothing quite like taking an easy drive in Bluffton as a way to relax and unwind, but a sudden auto accident can change that. Rest assured you'll have the right coverage by allowing Nationwide and J Wagner Agency LLC to take care of your auto insurance needs. Together, we work to remain up-to-date on your life with an On Your Side Review so that you're prepared for the unexpected.
To help get things back to normal as quickly as possible, we take action well before an accident so that the resulting fallout won't cause you more headache. Our goal is to make sure your motorcycle, car, truck, RV, ATV, or van is restored to its former glory as soon as possible should you ever be involved in an accident. J Wagner Agency LLC will also make sure you reap the benefits of having an exemplary protection plan.
Don't wait for disaster to strike before you take action to protect yourself, your vehicle, your passengers, and others on the road. We provide expertise and personalization to your life so that we can make sure you have the right coverage. Give us a call at (419) 358-2096 to discuss your options for a plan that meets your individual needs. We'd also be happy to see you in person at our location at 105 N Main St.
The J Wagner Agency LLC has all the expertise you need to find a home insurance policy that makes sense for your property. Your risk profile can be influenced by a number of factors, down to your exact city block and street address. However, homeowner's risk isn't just about the Bluffton neighborhood in which you live. For example, you may have a detached garage, swimming pool, or an aging roof. In any case, let J Wagner Agency LLC or one of our other knowledgeable agents explain the details of relevant coverage programs including other structures, umbrella liability, and Better Roof Replacement®.
J Wagner Agency LLC has partnered with Nationwide to deliver superior home insurance solutions to Bluffton homeowners. Like any homeowner, you want to know that both your home and your family can return to normal after a covered loss. There are no extra hassles with the On Your Side® Claims Service. To make things even easier, you can opt in to Nationwide's Brand New Belongings®.
There's no reason to let personalized options give you headaches when choosing your coverage. Call the J Wagner Agency LLC, and we'll be your no-nonsense guide to Bluffton home insurance. Buy a policy directly over the phone, or schedule an appointment. Our office is located at 105 N Main St.
The business insurance agents at J Wagner Agency LLC can help you understand how to manage your company's risk and identify possible gaps in your coverage. Along with liability and asset protection, for example, you can get coverage for losses in the case of a temporary shutdown of your business. Our agents have expertise in finding insurance solutions for businesses in virtually every industry of the Bluffton economy.
There are also important decisions to discuss that go beyond OH business requirements and your company's individual risk profile. As the owner, you'll want to make sure, for example, that your policy structure meets your month-to-month budget crunch and end-of-year fiscal goals. To this point, Nationwide offers flexible billing options that can be matched with different revenue and expenditure schedules. And if the day ever comes when the life and health of your business depends on making a claim, you'll be dealing with Nationwide's On Your Side® Claims Service.
The experts at J Wagner Agency LLC offer local knowledge, risk management expertise, and good old-fashioned customer service. We can talk about your coverage in person at our office, located at 105 N Main St. You can also call us at (419) 358-2096 to get protection for the business you've worked so hard to build.
Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.
The J Wagner Agency LLC also offers products in OH. Please call for information on products in those states.
