Coronavirus Resources
Learn what steps Nationwide is taking and how to help protect yourself and others.

Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. in Plain City, OH

Learn about our insurance products

  • Car Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Home Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service
1-800-421-35351-800-421-3535

Our Insurance Products

The Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. in Plain City, OH provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Car Insurance

    Get a personalized policy solution with Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc.. Our agents will take the time to understand your auto coverage priorities whether your household residing in Plain City includes a first-time driver, specialty vehicle, or specific financial concerns. No matter what your priorities, the versatile policy options and coverage programs from Nationwide have enabled Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. to serve motorists in neighborhoods across Plain City.

    Looking for additional motorist services? Rental reimbursement, towing and labor and roadside assistance offer peace of mind should the day come when your vehicle has seen one too many Washington winters. Or maybe you're looking for more affordable coverage. Talk to Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. or one of our other agents about available policy discounts. This includes discounts such as family plans and good student discounts, as well as anti-theft and defensive-driving incentives. Plus, there's more than one way to create coverage that's easier on the pocketbook. The Vanishing Deductible® program rewards Plain City drivers for each year of claims-free driving.

    Better yet, shopping for auto insurance doesn't need to take a bunch of your time or patience. Get a policy recommendation quickly and confidently with Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc.. Call us at (614) 873-1088 to discuss coverage details and to buy a policy directly over the phone. You can also schedule a visit with our 7450 Industrial Pkwy office.

  • Home Insurance

    Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. has teamed up with Nationwide to help you find the right home insurance package for your needs. This includes evaluating both your home and any belongings important to you. With our Valuables Plus® coverage, you can protect expensive items such as works of art, antiques, or jewelry; and replacements are easier than ever with our Brand New Belongings® coverage. Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. can answer any questions you have about protecting you and your family's most treasured possessions.

    The state of your home also comes in to play when determining what kind of home coverage is best for you. Any detached home additions are also important to evaluating your coverage needs, such as a pool or storage shed. Location also plays an important role in choosing the right home insurance. In Plain City, everything from zoning to weather can affect your coverage. Since Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. is local to Plain City, our agents are knowledgeable of any local factors that may impact your coverage.

    Picking home insurance is a very manageable process when you have the right partner by your side. Give Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. or any of our other agents a call today at (614) 873-1088 and find out how to get started. You can also come visit us in person at 7450 Industrial Pkwy. We look forward to meeting you.

  • Life Insurance

    If you are thinking about purchasing a life insurance policy in Plain City, you might have a few concerns about the process. You are probably familiar with purchasing insurance for your vehicles and home. However, life insurance requires you to exercise a little more due diligence. Think of life insurance as a long-term, personal investment. The right coverage can provide financial stability for your family. The wrong coverage could leave them with unexpected expenses.

    At Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc., we work with Nationwide to provide you with many insurance options to protect your most valuable assets. We understand the need for financial security and the challenges you may encounter in achieving it. We are here to help provide you and your loved ones with friendly and professional assistance in protecting the items and people you cherish the most.

    You want the best rates possible for your budget. For you to receive it, you need to consider which types of life insurance you need. Making this decision is not always easy. Fortunately, Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. and any of our team members are available to assist. There is some industry language you may not be familiar with that can make it challenging for you to understand policy options. We also offer different levels of coverage with varying death benefits and payment options.

    Your policy is only as good as your insurer’s reputation, experience and coverage options. To learn more about our products and how they can benefit you, call (614) 873-1088 to speak with one of our team members, or stop by 7450 Industrial Pkwy,Plain City,OH,43064 to discuss your insurance needs in our office.


    LAW-0241AO (05/18)

  • Business Insurance

    Whether you operate a golf course, medical clinic, or auto repair shop, coverage from Nationwide can fulfill all the small business insurance requirements that apply to Plain City companies. Let Nationwide Insurance: Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. help make sure that your customers and employees are protected, while also allowing your company to move forward when covered damages do occur.

    The versatile risk management products from Nationwide are backed by strong value, attractive discounts, and the superior On Your Side® Claims Service. Moreover, flexible billing helps meet your financial scheduling needs, while different payment options can prevent insurance from becoming another logistical hassle. From customized policies to good old fashioned customer service, it's all part of the package Nationwide Insurance: Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. offers our Plain City business clients.

    No matter how well you know your business, there always seems to be a few lingering questions about the right coverage for your company. Whether it's the location of your storefront, the size of your commercial fleet, or the feasibility of new employee benefits, let Nationwide Insurance: Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. answer any and all questions you might have. Give us a call at (614) 873-1088 to talk about your coverage or to schedule an office appointment at 7450 Industrial Pkwy.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

The Mitchell Insurance Agency Inc. also offers products in AZ. Please call for information on products in those states.