Elmer R Midgett Associate Agent
Carolyn K Payton Business Manager
Michelle Scarborough Customer Service Representative
Amy Colanero Agency Manager
Madeleine Land Associate Agent
Jan Presgraves Associate Agent
Rhonda Hansen Associate Agent
Midgett Insurance Agency was founded in 1973 by Elmer R. Midgett, Jr., in downtown Manteo, NC. He created a tradition of exceptional and personalized customer service, which continues today.
After graduating from James Madison University in Virginia, Paul Tine moved to the Outer Banks in 1995 and married Whitney Tine. He began working in the family business in 1998 and purchased the agency in 2005. Since that time, the agency has grown to two locations, acquired CDA Insurance of Kill Devil Hills and has over 15 employees serving clients in the Outer Banks, Northeast NC and Virginia.
We are a community-based agency and are committed to protecting the assets and livelihood of our neighbors.
Midgett Insurance Agency has locations in Manteo and Kitty Hawk. We have specialists who are trained to assist our clients in each area of their personal and professional lives through proactive, predictable interactions. Our Agency knows that insurance exists for one reason only, to make things right when things go wrong. So we work hard to make sure that all our clients are covered the way they want to be and that we keep our promise to be On Your Side.