Paul N Tine, Insurance Agent

Midgett Insurance Agency

Paul N Tine
Agency Owner
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM 9:00 AM - 5:00 PMClosed Today Closed Today

Send Midgett Insurance Agency an Email

Main Number
(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930

Get an insurance quote

Get an insurance quote

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Paul N Tine an Email


Store Hours:

Day of the WeekHours
Mon9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tue9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thu9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Fri9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Learn about our insurance products

  • Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.
  • Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.
  • Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.
  • Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service

About Paul N Tine

Paul Tine is married to his wife, Whitney, and they have two sons.
  • Paul Tine graduated Cum Laude from James Madison University in Harrisonburg, Virginia.
Languages Spoken
  • English
Licensed In
  • NC
  • VA
  • Auto
  • Life
  • Home
  • Business
Agent Qualifications
  • Paul started with Midgett Insurance Agency in 1998 and bought the Agency in 2005.
  • Champion Award
  • Presidents Conference Award
  • Nationwide Life Council
Community Activities
  • Paul Tine serves in various organizations including: President- North Banks Rotary, Chair Elect- Outer Banks Chamber of Commerce, Chairman- Create the Future, Den Master - Tiger Scouts, Board Member- Roanoke Island Historical Association (Lost Colony)

Our Insurance Products

The Nationwide Insurance: Midgett Insurance Agency in Manteo, NC provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.
  • Auto Insurance
    Since opening their doors, Midgett Insurance Agency has been helping Manteo motorists find auto insurance coverage that speaks to their personal priorities. Whether it's the everyday vehicle, weekend joyride, or any number of specialty vehicles, know that you're protected with policy coverage that makes sense for your household. From family plans and good student discounts to anti-theft and paperless billing options, find great coverage at a great price with Midgett Insurance Agency.

    Eliminating coverage gaps and finding affordable policies aren't the only advantages of partnering with Nationwide and Midgett Insurance Agency. The Vanishing Deductible® program acts as a reward for each year of claims-free driving you accrue. This reward is on top of the separate accident-free and defensive-driving discounts that Manteo drivers can earn with Nationwide. There are also secondary services that can be added on to your policy including rental reimbursement, towing, and roadside assistance. And should you ever need it, the On Your Side® Claims Service offers a list of qualified shops and a secure way to monitor the repairs.

    Learn how to choose a personalized Nationwide solution without getting frustrated or spending an entire day on research. Talk to Midgett Insurance Agency and make decisions with speed and confidence. Give us a call at (252) 473-3930. The office is located at 503 Cypress Lane.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Homeowners Insurance
    Manteo homeowners are experts when it comes to knowing everything there is to know about their house and property, but not all homeowners may be familiar with everything contained in their home insurance policies. Some policies are designed with a one-size-fits-all philosophy and may not provide adequate protection for special features like swimming pools, garages, carports, tree houses, and children's play equipment. Your home insurance policy should not be a mystery. Let the team at Midgett Insurance Agency help you determine whether your policy is really providing the kind of protection your home requires. For years, Paul N Tine has helped homeowners discover the right coverage for their needs.

    Every home and residential property is a little bit different, which means coverage should be tailored to meet each situation. Changes to the property, such as renovation or remodeling, may require taking a look at your current policy. As a Nationwide agency, we provide our customers with personalized coverage solutions. This approach helps make sure you are getting the most value for your money.

    We look forward to helping you access Nationwide home insurance and much more. Contact Paul N Tine today by calling (252) 473-3930, or drop by our office on 503 Cypress Lane. Our experienced agents are ready to help you improve your existing coverage or discover new policy options.

    Get an insurance quote

  • Life Insurance
    If you are thinking about purchasing a life insurance policy in Manteo, you might have a few concerns about the process. You are probably familiar with purchasing insurance for your vehicles and home. However, life insurance requires you to exercise a little more due diligence. Think of life insurance as a long-term, personal investment. The right coverage can provide financial stability for your family. The wrong coverage could leave them with unexpected expenses.

    At Midgett Insurance Agency, we work with Nationwide to provide you with many insurance options to protect your most valuable assets. We understand the need for financial security and the challenges you may encounter in achieving it. We are here to help provide you and your loved ones with friendly and professional assistance in protecting the items and people you cherish the most.

    You want the best rates possible for your budget. For you to receive it, you need to consider which types of life insurance you need. Making this decision is not always easy. Fortunately, Paul N Tine and any of our team members are available to assist. There is some industry language you may not be familiar with that can make it challenging for you to understand policy options. We also offer different levels of coverage with varying death benefits and payment options.

    Your policy is only as good as your insurer’s reputation, experience and coverage options. To learn more about our products and how they can benefit you, call (252) 473-3930 to speak with one of our team members, or stop by 503 Cypress Lane,Manteo,NC,27954 to discuss your insurance needs in our office.

    LAW-0241AO (05/18)

    Get an insurance quote

  • Business Insurance
    Acting proactively is one key to small-business success. Whether you run a dry cleaner business, florist shop, real estate office, attorneys office, or something else entirely, we at Midgett Insurance Agency have many excellent insurance solutions to offer you thanks to our working with Nationwide. Nationwide and its agents insure more than 500,000 small businesses all across the United States, and we are committed to providing quality coverage in Manteo that is affordable and meets your needs.

    If you are uncertain about where to start with your insurance plan, we offer On Your Side® Reviews to assess your business and to make recommendations to the types of insurance coverage you may need. Another good way to approach the matter is to get a business owners policy, or BOP, specific to your industry type. After that, you can add on options to fit specific situations. For example, such additional coverage options include workers compensation insurance, cyber liability insurance, accounts receivable insurance, and crime insurance. Even two businesses in the same industry may have vastly different insurance needs, so we make many coverage choices available. Business size, finances, and target customer base can often factor into insurance coverage as well.

    It is natural to wonder about the amount and type of coverage that is appropriate for your business. Contact our office today to get answers. You can give us a call at (252) 473-3930 or visit us on 503 Cypress Lane to protect your business as much as possible.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

    Get an insurance quote

The Midgett Insurance Agency also offers products in NC, VA. Please call for information on products in those states.

About the Midgett Insurance Agency

Elmer R Midgett, Insurance Agent

Elmer R Midgett Associate Agent

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Elmer R Midgett an Email

Carolyn K Payton, Insurance Agent

Carolyn K Payton Business Manager

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Carolyn K Payton an Email

Michelle Scarborough, Insurance Agent

Michelle Scarborough Customer Service Representative

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Michelle Scarborough an Email

Amy Colanero, Insurance Agent

Amy Colanero Agency Manager

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Amy Colanero an Email

Madeleine Land, Insurance Agent

Madeleine Land Associate Agent

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Madeleine Land an Email

Jan Presgraves, Insurance Agent

Jan Presgraves Associate Agent

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Jan Presgraves an Email

Rhonda Hansen, Insurance Agent

Rhonda Hansen Associate Agent

(252) 473-3930(252) 473-3930
(252) 473-5947(252) 473-5947

Send Rhonda Hansen an Email

3900 N Croatan Highway
Kitty Hawk, NC 27949
Main Number
(252) 261-4684(252) 261-4684
Click to visit page of this location
Midgett Insurance Agency was founded in 1973 by Elmer R. Midgett, Jr., in downtown Manteo, NC. He created a tradition of exceptional and personalized customer service, which continues today. After graduating from James Madison University in Virginia, Paul Tine moved to the Outer Banks in 1995 and married Whitney Tine. He began working in the family business in 1998 and purchased the agency in 2005. Since that time, the agency has grown to two locations, acquired CDA Insurance of Kill Devil Hills and has over 15 employees serving clients in the Outer Banks, Northeast NC and Virginia. We are a community-based agency and are committed to protecting the assets and livelihood of our neighbors.
Midgett Insurance Agency has locations in Manteo and Kitty Hawk. We have specialists who are trained to assist our clients in each area of their personal and professional lives through proactive, predictable interactions. Our Agency knows that insurance exists for one reason only, to make things right when things go wrong. So we work hard to make sure that all our clients are covered the way they want to be and that we keep our promise to be On Your Side.

Average customer rating for Midgett Insurance Agency

503 Cypress Lane
Ste B
Manteo, NC 27954