Starkweather & Shepley Insurance in Fort Myers, FL

Learn about our insurance products

  • Auto Insurance

    Get an auto insurance policy you can count on from Nationwide.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Protect your house and personal property by choosing the right insurance coverage from Nationwide.

  • Life Insurance

    Let us help you select life insurance coverage that meets your needs, your life and your budget.

  • Business Insurance

    Cover your business with commercial insurance from Nationwide.

Member support

24/7 Claims Service
1-800-421-35351-800-421-3535

Our Insurance Products

The Starkweather & Shepley Insurance in Fort Myers, FL provides the following products. To learn more about each insurance product, click on the links below.

  • Auto Insurance

    What do you desire from an auto insurance company? Many people ask for a smooth and easy claims process as well as attentive service. Starkweather & Shepley Insurance has teamed up with Nationwide to deliver precisely that experience. Clients are not a number to us, they are individuals. Everyone's car insurance requirements in Fort Myers differ, and we recognize that.

    Nationwide offers a wide-ranging array of programs and coverage levels so that you are able to pick what is right for you. For example, the many coverage offerings include Liability coverage, Collision coverage, Medical Payments coverage, and Roadside Assistance coverage. Nationwide not only provides auto insurance but also has programs for motorcycles, RVs, and other special vehicle types. Of course, insurance needs change from year to year, so Nationwide offers an annual On Your Side® Review to look at your specific needs.

    Give Lawrence E Keefe a call today at (239) 344-0023 to get a conversation going about car insurance needs. Face-to-face chats are great too, just make an appointment and stop by the office at 13420 Parker Commons Blvd. We can provide more information about discounts you may qualify for, such as Multi-Policy discounts, Accident-Free discounts, Paperless documents, and Good Student discounts.

  • Homeowners Insurance

    Starkweather & Shepley Insurance can help you shop for one of the most important products you'll ever buy - the home insurance policy that will protect your home assets. Learn from our Fort Myers agents what types of damages to include in your coverage and what claim amounts make sense for your property. For as tightly knit as Fort Myers neighborhoods are, no two households are exactly the same, even within 33912.

    For this reason, Nationwide offers a number of different home insurance products for more personalized coverage. Dwelling coverage, for example, offers financial protection for floor coverings and built-in appliances. Contents coverage includes assets like furniture, clothing, and a few other essential belongings. Valuables Plus® covers specific types of high-value items that you may keep in your Fort Myers home. Or you can even take advantage of Nationwide's exclusive Brand New Belongings® program.

    Best of all, there's no reason to feel overwhelmed by any of these decisions. Let Starkweather & Shepley Insurance walk you through the options and clearly explain your policy choices. Simply give us a call at (239) 344-0023. Or, if you're in the 33912 area during office hours, swing by our Fort Myers location at 13420 Parker Commons Blvd, and we can discuss your home insurance options in person.

  • Life Insurance

    Bringing home a new baby, like many of life’s happy events, also brings on new responsibilities. New obligations can be more easily shouldered if you take steps now to plan ahead. In order to provide long-term financial security for your family, you need a Fort Myers life insurance agent who can help you understand the types of life insurance that best suit your family’s needs.

    The agents at Starkweather & Shepley Insurance will help you safeguard your family’s future by helping you select the right life insurance. We will explain term versus permanent insurance and answer all your questions. We are here to help you assess your needs and will explain the difference between whole life insurance and universal life insurance.

    Our agency will help you determine the appropriate level of coverage for you and your family. There are several considerations when deciding the amount of coverage you need. Besides funeral and burial costs, you should consider current debts such as your mortgage, car loans and credit card debt.

    You may also want to include child care and long-term educational expenses when figuring coverage amount. Whether your family has one or two sources of income, you should think about covering lost income for a specified number of years. We will also help you determine the number of years for which you need coverage.

    Whether you have a new baby on the way, or you brought your baby home several months ago, now is the time to plan for life’s eventualities. Call (239) 344-0023 and ask for Lawrence E Keefe or visit us at 13420 Parker Commons Blvd,Fort Myers,FL,33912. We will be happy to work with you to make sure your family’s financial security is always protected.


    LAW-0245AO (05/18)

  • Business Insurance

    Maybe you're looking for targeted business coverage or maybe you're looking for wide-ranging policy protections as part of a new business continuity plan. Either way, Nationwide Insurance: Starkweather & Shepley Insurance can help you protect past gains, while also positioning your company for future growth.

    Through Nationwide, our agents offer business insurance for Fort Myers companies that operate in a wide range of industries from food and beverage to building management to professional contractors. Product offerings include liability, property, and commercial auto insurance. For some companies, it's also crucial to get operating loss coverage to ensure money is coming in even if something forces their business to close shop for a time. Likewise, flexible billing options help you meet premium obligations regardless of how your company's budget is structured.

    It sounds complicated, but it doesn't have to be. In fact, to combine several products in a single policy, have one of the risk management experts at Nationwide Insurance: Starkweather & Shepley Insurance help you build a business owner's policy with coverage that's personalized for your company. Call us at (239) 344-0023 to discuss your Fort Myers business insurance or to set up an appointment at the office located at 13420 Parker Commons Blvd.

    Nationwide offers small business resources to help you strengthen your business, such as financial calculators and information and articles on marketing and cash flow management. Learn more at the Business Solutions Center.

The Starkweather & Shepley Insurance also offers products in AL, AK, AZ, AR, CA, CO, CT, DE, DC, FL, GA, HI, ID, IL, IN, IA, KS, LA, ME, MD, MA, MI, MN, MS, MO, MT, NE, NV, NH, NM, NY, NC, ND, OH, OK, OR, PA, RI, SC, SD, TN, TX, UT, VT, VA, WA, WV, WI, WY, KY, NJ. Please call for information on products in those states.

Learning Center

Learning center articleHow does gap insurance work?

Discover what gap insurance does and how this auto policy can help you.

Learning center articleAre hazard and homeowners insurance the same?

Take a look at what make up the differences between hazard insurance and homeowners insurance.

Learning center articleComprehensive vs. collision insurance

Understand the differences between these two common types of auto insurance.